Below are pictures identified with he help of Dr. Frank Guarnieri.
Things to observe:
Mandibles shorter than the pronutum, with just one inner tooth.
Very developed front legs tibia particularly in the females.
Very black underneath, which is a very important identification clue. I've got a hunch that probably some people are mixing them up with the Pinching Bug Lucanus capreolus, but the latter have got golden femurs and their mandibles are quite different. See below for a comparative photo that I've taken of dried specimens.
Things to observe:
This beetle was found in remarkable circumstances, click on the photo to find out more about it in the Bugguide where I've uploaded a photo-story.
Female and male Lucanus placidus, left and middle, Lucanus capreolus male, right.
Photo by Maria Fremlin, 14 February 2006.
It would be lovely to have more finds of this beetle and to know its common names as well.
If you happen to see some, please show your finds directly in the Bugguide.